| July 5, 2004 Bangkok Journal Entry by B. Berry |
This was our third day in Bangkok. It was a long one, and it was an extreme
of experiences, but it was our best.
We were off at eight to Thammarat University. There we walked through a crowded
campus and made our way to a very handsome boardroom used by the faculty of
the Humanities division - a great square conference table with microphones and
gleaming surface (finished underneath as well as on top), tilting armchairs,
IBM Powerpoint too. Plus a huge Buddhist altar and a framed portrait of the
King, in an easel. He wore his medals and -I checked on this - a boy scout scarf.
Our speakers for the 4-hour seminar that followed were two: Doctor Charnvit
Kasetsiri, again, and Professor Sirilaksana Khoman, the chair of the Economics
faculty and daughter of a former foreign minister. She was terrific too, warm
and able and possessed of great English spoken with a British accent. I am thinking
we had two very distinguished professors here, very much with rare international
interests and extraordinary experience, not time servers. Thank you, EWC.
They covered the present state of Thailand as a democracy. I will try as best
I can to sum up my impressions but they are bound to be partial and subject
to error. The speakers focused on the performance of Thaksin Shinawatra, the
prime minister, who was presented as a populist, wily and quick, an endless
fount of economic schemes. But it seems he is devoted to funneling money to
every in-law, cousin, and brother that he can uncover. The faculty of the university,
we were told, spends a good deal of time researching the obscure names that
appear buried in trade agreements and legislation (his party has a majority
in parliament, the first PM ever to have it). These individuals always turn
out to be those most benefited, and they also turn out to be loyal and very
junior employees of the Thaksin companies. Thaksin began as a silk exporter
but grew to rapid wealth with monopolies in telecommunications.
They also covered the impact of the '97 financial crash on Thailand and the
shape of its recovery, which is still underway. The concrete columns allover
town, it seems, are known to all Thais as the memorial to the crash: they were
going to hold up an elevated highway and a second skytrain, both victims of
the crash.
Thailand it seems was very vulnerable because the financial pattern was to
borrow with short-term repayments -a year or less-but to invest the money in
long-term investments. Here as in so many developing countries, access to credit
is far from democratic or even rational, since earning/expenditure reporting
is opaque and the banks' requirements for qualifying loans are sketchy. I wonder
too, just how available those loans are, to those without family influence.
Nevertheless they spoke with hope. Charnvit told in depth the story of the
1973 student revolution that resulted in a constitution and the fall of a three-person
dictatorship. But he spoke of the cost. There were dead and injured at the time:
they were victims of military actions after peace and compromise had been reached,
thanks to the intervention of the King. And Charnvit himself was among the 100
faculty who risked all at the height of the confrontation to sign a petition
demanding a constitution.
Three years after this victory, however, one of the dictators returned from
exile, staged a coup, and got bloody retribution for his fall. If I have the
time-frame right, this occurred in 1976, and it featured a deliberate, all-night
massacre of students trapped in an athletic field on campus. Hundreds were killed
and many more, I believe, were wounded. Shades of Armies of the Night! Charnvit
fled to the United States about this time, and taught at Berkeley.
The president of Thammasat, who had headed the Free Thai underground during
WWII, escaped to China it seems.He was never able to return, dying there 17
years later. I missed his name-I have to see the names written out to get them.
He had had to flee his riverside home in a small boat with the help of a British
man. Many faculty fled to the jungles of the Northeast and joined the Communist
partisans there, moderating that movement somewhat I gathered. After three years
or more those who survived were able to return to teaching posts and resume
their lives. Eventually this dictator was disgraced and deposed but if I heard
this right, he lives in wealthy exile in the mid-east somewhere.
Two items I want to follow up: the details and chronology of this military
repression, and just how Chuck, my brother, used to trace deposits in Swiss
banks with the help of hackers. Sirilakasana showed some interest in this idea.
I also want to send some movies to Charnvit, he is really a fan. Running on
Empty comes to mind. He has not seen it. He enjoyed Coming Home, he said, which
just may be the best of the Vietnam era movies, in my none-too-humble opInIOn.
I have my own impressions about all of this, as I have had in other countries
where the public face is so genteel and pious. Societies I know better, such
as Colombia, which wear a religious and aristocratic face in ceremony, often
have the wildest and most vigorous undergrounds. I am thinking now of the secret
business life of civil servants, military officers, and politicians, and of
course, of the flaming sex trade here in Bangkok. Bolivia I know has its military
in frank control, aristocrats on the outs, and a church that is small, discredited,
and reactionary. It also has a grim and graceless social life, and a bunch of
fierce but impoverished unions. My impression has been that there is probably
less going on in the secret sector there. It is far from utopia but the cards
are on the table.
Colombia, much more gracious on the surface, truly is an oligarchy, and the
wealth of the underground cocaine economy vastly exceeds that of the public
economy. That of course is actually a dogfight between narco cartels and secret
military politico cartels. The public war against leftist guerillas actually
masks a battle for huge drug revenues. I believe the Colombian military cheerfully
manipulates official US interest in counter-insurgency and drugs, to collect
military assets used to further its own profitable trade. My pipe-dream for
years has been to tackle this story as a free lance. Ah well, I still have trouble
accepting life as an educator, it's a little short on adventure.
At lunch I ducked downstairs with Teh, one of our grad-student guides, to see
the statue they call the "Thinker". He is a kind of Thai demigod who
is a patron saint to the students. He was featured in a poster in the conference
room, and Teh explained him to me. The Thinker did not want to be photographed,
it seems. My shutter release got sticky on one camera body, and the film advance
jammed on the second. Teh suggested that I ask his permission to be photographed,
and I did that, and it went better. I should have known better. I think this
lithe and youthful, Pan-like figure may have a little power left over to vex
an impertinent Westerner, sure enough.
We also saw a BBC video about the King's 50th anniversary (1946-1996), very
subtle, and it became much easier to understand why he is so loved. He does
a great deal by example and by exquisite timing, and he makes the most of very
little temporal power.
Then we were off by bus to the Wat Phra Keo and Royal Palace complex. This
is the late nineteenth century capital, really, all temples and towers jammed
inside a wall. This plus a genuine, lived-in palace, right in the middle of
it all. The place was resplendent beyond what I could grasp: gold and mosaics
of glass everywhere, temples, columns, pagodas, towers, pavilions, huge dragons
and demons, painted carvings, and more gold everywhere. One temple housed the
Emerald Buddha too. 1 had to use my camera on close-up details and the clearest
of the open spaces, not much in between, as 1 tried to plan how 1 would convey
this to a class. Without this for a viewpoint 1 would have been overwhelmed.
There is nothing in American experience like it, that's for sure. It was way
too much. 1 think maybe Walt Disney had a former life in this complex.
At one point 1 sat on the ground to photograph some mythical creature, and
a Thai man all sweaty just like me, called me over. He had English and we talked
a bit while his wife and kids stood by. "I love America," he said.
"Really strong. The biggest. 1 love that..."
Somehow 1 lost the guide and missed the rendezvous at closing time. 1 searched
for the bus, and ran three long blocks at one point because 1 thought 1 saw
our bus in traffic. As 1 sat recovering on a park bench 1 was hit on by a tall,
emaciated transsexual prostitute in a black miniskirt and net stockings. He
was pitiful and he looked like the next fix of his chosen drug would finish
him. 1 was too beat to even think about disgust. 1 felt a wave of pity instead.
Finally 1 hired a tuk-tuk and fired out of there, out of breath and bathed
in sweat. By chance 1 overtook our bus a few blocks away. Charlene did not,
though. She missed it too.
Back at the university, we had an illustrated lecture (how Bangkok came to
be) in a blessedly cool classroom. It began with Anna's King Mongkut, a shrimpy
and weathered little guy who looked not one whisker like Yul Brynner. He it
was who became an Anglophile, met Queen Victoria, and came home to outfit the
palace guards and other elite units in British-type uniforms - all in rainbow
colors like yellow, sky blue, and vermilion.
Afterwards we walked the campus at dusk with our lecturer, history professor
Kwandee Altavuthichai, spelled correctly 1 hope. She showed us the tower that
is the university's emblem, with the statue of the president who had to flee
to China in front of it. 1 asked how long it had taken for his reputation to
be restored after 1976, and she said it has still not been restored except among
the few. She showed us his house too.
With some trepidation, she took us to the athletic field where the massacre
had taken place. She had said that she was afraid she would cry there, and she
did. She spoke of five of her students who were among the dead, and of two others
who escaped and came to her home to keep her from coming down that night. 1
don't think she makes this tour that often. 1 was touched, not to mention thrown back in time. 1 can't stand it, that soldiers can gun down the unarmed
and then find impunity when these things are over.
Then it was off on foot, through traffic and over broken walkways in darkness,
to Khaosan road, the trekker market. There were only a few of us now. Many had
slipped away by taxi in twos and threes after a very long day. We visited an
18th century French fort at the second of the city's three moats, saw a few
hundred cheerful twenty-somethings doing aerobics in the park there too. Elliot
the grad student turned up at some drinking spot we passed, and disappeared
again when he realized we had a professor in tow. I shared a beer with the professor
and Namji and Margaret, skipped dinner due to the heat. Then we caught a taxi
back to the hotel to pack and otherwise clear things up for tomorrow's departure.
At the mall adjacent to the hotel I picked up my laundry and my nine rolls of
slides - looking good, Hooray! Mostly Saigon, the Cao Dai temple, and Cu Chi.
Bedtime for me was 12:30 and it felt more like 2:30.